It’s clear that most people see and believe these two pieces
of art to be separate entities, which I fully agree, however it seems almost
inhuman to not compare them. Without comparisons, we wouldn’t have the ability
to decide the things we like.
Personally speaking, I would choose WWS over R+J. Why?
Because it has singing and dancing, big surprise, though this is not to
discredit R+J. In fact, I believe that WWS gives new life to R+J, for those
(like me) who find Shakespeare’s work a bit daunting. After knowing a version
of the R+J story, I think many people would want to research the root of WWS
and discover the play which the musical was based off of. Not only does this enhance
your knowledge of the musical, but it also can make it more enjoyable by find
the similarities, and how they have been modernized.
Some of the comparisons (which have been mentioned) are…
·
The Montagues and The Capulets – The Jets and
The Sharkes
·
Romeo falls in love and gets killed – Tony falls
in love and gets killed
·
Juliet has a relative killed by her lover –
Maria has a relative killed by her lover
·
The Prince tells the families that if there was
another riot that the heads of each family would be killed – The Lieutenant
tells the Puerto Ricans and the Americans that if they get into another fight,
they’ll be taken to jail.
·
Both stories have an accidental death, which
causes the hero to kill their lover’s relative.\
·
Both a meeting moment at the dance
·
Both have a romantic moment on an outside
structure
·
And both have a fight near the end, which leads
to death.
Of course we could do this whole comparison thing with Romeo
and Juliet and the animated film Gnomeo and Juliet. But I’ll leave that for
another day.